Bible Violence is Exaggerated

Kill CanaanitesAs we work our way through some of the theories about how God can condone and command violence in the Bible, we come to a view which basically states that the violence is exaggerated.

The basic premise is that we misread the Bible when we think that the Israelites actually killed all the Canaanites (or whatever people group is in view). Sometimes the Bible is exaggerating in the number of people that were killed while other times the Bible says that all the people were killed when in fact they were not.

Then there are those cases where the terminology for “destruction” need not refer to death, but could refer to something else, such as being forced to leave the land or make the decision to join forces with the Israelites.

In other words, this position has several elements and perspectives, depending on which book you read or which scholar you listen to, but the main elements of this theory are described below (Note: Many hold various versions of this view, but you can read one summary of it on the Eternity Bible College blog).

Others Could Join Israel

First, God’s ultimate goal was for the conquered people to repent of their sin, see that God was worthy of worship and obedience, and join with Israel in following Him. Examples of this are found in some of the Egyptian people who joined with Israel at the Exodus (Exod 12:38), Rahab siding with the Israelite spies against her own people and then becoming one of the Israelites after their conquest of Jericho (Josh 6:22-23), and the Gibeonites choosing to be servants of Israel rather than face annihilation (Josh 9:9).

The Canaanites were Driven Out

Secondly, when people did not side with God in this way, God did not actually command the Israelites to kill and slaughter those that remained, but to “drive them out” of the land, that is, to force them to leave the land of Canaan and go elsewhere (cf. Num 21:32; Deut 9:1; 11:23; 18:14; 19:1; 23:27-30; etc.).

Though passages such as Joshua 10:40 indicate that the Israelites destroyed everything that had breath, other contexts reveal that Israel did not, in fact, kill everything that had breath for there were many Canaanites still left in the land for years to come (cf. Josh 13:1; 16:10; 17:12; 23:7, 12-14; Deut 20”16-17; 28:63; Jer 38:2, 17).

Only Enemy Combatants Were Killed

Similarly, some argue that when the Bible talks about killing “women and children” this doesn’t really mean “women and children” but means “everyone,” in which case, the actual women and children could be spared, or more likely, were not even present in the “military outposts” which Joshua and the Israelites attacked.

Apart from Joshua 6 and 8, which mentions women and children [who were not killed], all other accounts of Israel killing Canaanites in the conquest include—and only include—combatants, not civilians.

The Numbers are Highly Exaggerated

Finally, in relation to this view, some argue that the numbers of people involved were highly exaggerated, possibly by as much as ten or a hundredfold.

Analysis of this View

So in the end, this view holds that while there was a conquest of Canaan, it probably did not involve killing any women and children. Indeed, there very little killing at all. Most of the inhabitants of the land were “driven out” of the land, though some were allowed to remain (to the detriment of future Israelite morality). Of the few people who were actually killed, they were enemy combatants, and such casualties are to be expected in any war.

Kill the Canaanites

This is a compelling argument, and is probably quite true in many regards. For example, I am not opposed to the idea of exaggerated numbers in some of these accounts, as I think it helps make much more sense of what is happening and helps explain some of the problems inherent within the text.

Also, it may be true that no women and children were actually killed in the Canaanite conquest, and that only enemy combatants were killed. However, even if this is true, there is still the difficulty with God commanding the Israelites to engage in such warfare, especially in light of the teachings and example of Jesus.

Even if only a couple hundred people were actually killed at the command of God in all of the Old Testament (and it is unlikely that the number is that low), we still have to deal with the main problem, which is how God can command the killing of anyone. Reducing the numbers and making them only male does not fully solve the problem.

God of the Old Testament and JesusThis post is part of my ongoing series on how to understand the violence of God in the Old Testament. Specifically, I am trying to answer this question:

How can a God who says "Love your enemies" (Matthew 5:44) be the same God who instructs His people in the Old Testament to kill their enemies?

To see what I am arguing so far, click here.

Also, when I am done with this series of posts, I will be publishing them as a book. If you want a free digital copy of this book when it comes out, make sure you have subscribed to my email newsletter.

Leave a Comment by Sharing this Post with Others:

The comment section for this blog exists on YOUR social sites. Share below to get the conversation started.

I believe that inviting others into conversation with you is one of the best ways to study Scripture, do theology, and be the church.

I do, of course, want to interact with you as well, so if you tag me on your Facebook post (@Jeremy Myers or @RedeemingGod) and in your Tweet (@jeremyers1 or @RedeemingGod), I will do my best to join your conversation when possible.