One set of texts which are occasionally referenced in support of the Unconditional Election comes from the Olivet Discourse in Matthew 24. The reason these texts are cited is because they make reference to “the elect.”
And unless those days were shortened, no flesh would be saved; but for the elect’s sake those days will be shortened (Matthew 24:22).
For false christs and false prophets will rise and show great signs and wonders to deceive, if possible, even the elect (Matthew 24:24).
And He will send His angels with a great sound of a trumpet, and they will gather together His elect from the four winds, from one end of heaven to the other (Matthew 24:31).
These three texts clearly reference the elect, but we must remember that just because a Bible verse uses the word “elect,” this does not mean that the Calvinistic understanding of election is true.
One sometimes runs into Calvinists who argue that election is true because the Bible mentions election.
The question, however, is not whether or not the Bible mentions election, but rather what the Bible means when it mentions election. And when Matthew 24 refers to election, what it teaches is somewhat surprising, and in fact, seems to undermine the Calvinistic understanding of election.
Matthew 24 and Election
According to Calvinism, those who are elect are unconditionally chosen by God to receive eternal life. They are irresistibly brought by God into His family. Election occurs because a sovereign God rules and controls all.
Yet what is exceedingly strange in these texts from Matthew 24 which mention the elect, is that it appears that “even the elect” could be deceived and led astray by the false christs and false prophets that arise in the last days. If God sovereignly controls the beliefs and behaviors of His elect, then how is it that they could be deceived by false teaching? Indeed, Jesus says that God will cut short those days so that the elect will not die and will not be deceived.
To be even more specific, it is possible that when Jesus refers to “the elect” in this text, He might be specifically thinking of the Jewish elect people, so that when He refers to gathering the elect from the four winds, He is referring to gathering His people Israel back to Jerusalem from the four corners of the earth.
As a side note, it is important to recognize that when Jesus speaks about being “saved” in this passage (cf. Matthew 24:13, 22), He is not referring to justification or receiving eternal life, but to being delivered from death in this time of tribulation. The salvation in Matthew 24 is not about going to heaven when we die, but is about deliverance from physical death during times of tribulation (Wilkin, Grace New Testament Commentary, 110). Paul makes a similar statement about the Jews in Romans 11:26-27.
So when it comes to the discussion of election, Matthew 24 really doesn’t provide any new information about how one becomes elect or what interaction exists (if any) between the human and divine wills.
There is an indication that God does not sovereignly control the beliefs and behaviors of the elect, and since they themselves might be deceived by the false teaching of these last days, He intervenes to cut those days short, but other than this, there is little that this text adds to the discussion of election.
If you want to read more about Calvinism, check out other posts in this blog series: Words of Calvinism and the Word of God.
I love your posts on election. I haven’t read them all, but the ones I have read have been helpful because they’ve confirmed most of the positions I’ve taken on the same key verses for the book I’m working on.
We got your Radmacher books yesterday, by the way! Thanks! Who did you print them with? I noticed they were smaller than Amazon’s 6×9.
Great stuff
Your point regarding the Scriptures you quote above, Jeremy, possibly applying to Jews only is interesting and thought-provoking.
However, regardless of whether they are referring to Jews or believing Followers of every race, I question whether you can define the phrase, “elect’s sake” as meaning: “Jesus says that God will cut short those days so that the elect will not die and will not be deceived.”
The passage does NOT say that.
Even in the context of the Great Tribulation, your statement is from “Opinions One” and places your argument on extra-Biblical comment, in my opinion.
Blessings in Jesus, Gary in Toronto
I get the idea of death and deception from Matthew 24:7-12. When Jesus uses the word “saved” in verse 13, it points back to being saved from the things he just mentioned.
These are good examples (“elect” and “saved”) of taking English words from Bible translations and assuming that those words mean the same thing as the way I define them. The result may be damaging, dangerous and truly heretical theology.
Shawn, I liked your article on Election recently in one of the GIF newsletters. I think I cite it one of the posts.
I publish through CreateSpace. You can select various cover dimensions. I think that one is 5.5 x 8.5?
Ahh! So do we! I never noticed the other options!
I thought you all used some sort of printing company to print thousands of copies at a time?
We were. But I switched us to CreateSpace because the per-unit cost isn’t much more than going with a big printer, the upfront costs are way lower (maybe $250 vs $5000?), and it saves on storage space because we order books as we need them. We might go with a printer to do case-bound hardcovers for new books, but as far as reprinting and the journal is concerned, I think createspace is the way to go.
Definitely better. But you still ship from the office, right? So you place small orders and fulfill them directly, rather than placing each individual order through CS?
Right we fulfill through the office if people order through the magazine or website. Or they can order directly from Amazon, and we get a royalty.
Just published my book thru CreateSpace-& found its process and ease of use, refreshing. Modding hurt I had a great book from Jeremy about self publishing-thanks Jeremy!
Glad you found it helpful, Tony! I primarily wrote it for myself to remind me what to do every time! Ha!