A year after my encounter with Sandwich Board Evangelism, I found myself at Moody Bible Institute in Chicago. One of the core classes was a course on evangelism. As part of the course, some of the students went out every weekend to do street evangelism.

One weekend, I was guilt-tripped into joining them. (Have you ever noticed that guilt is a heavy motivator in evangelism — both in those who do it and in the message they preach? That should tell us something is wrong with evangelism.)

Street Corner Evangelism

Anyway, the approach these students used was a little more tasteful than that of Bullhorn Evangelist Red or the college campus Sandwich Board preacher. One student was a bit of an artist, and he set up a big easel on a corner of Michigan Avenue, and proceeded to draw Gospel-related images on the easel while preaching in a loud voice about the Gospel.

While he did that, the rest of us acted as “crowd primers.” It is normal street corner psychology that if a crowd is standing around watching something, you want to stop and see what is going on. So we “created the crowd.” We were supposed to walk up, acting like we were just people passing by, and then stop and watch him draw and listen to him preach.  After a dozen or so students had “stopped to listen” others would stop, watch, and listen as well.

The guy talked and drew for about five minutes, and then as he closed up, we were supposed to pull a Gospel tract out of our pocket and hand it to a stranger nearby and ask what they thought about Jesus and the message they had just heard, and if they had any questions or wanted us to pray with them.

Springing the Trap

I still remember feeling like we were setting a trap for people. It was even more strange because in my first attempt at this, there was about three students for every actual person. So when the presentation was over, each “unsaved” person got swarmed by three students handing them tracts and asking to pray with them. Imagine how they must have felt! They thought they were gathered with a bunch of other strangers on the sidewalk, only to find out that the vast majority of the crowd was fake, just waiting to pounce on their unsuspecting souls.

I don’t think we got any converts this day, but if we did, I don’t remember. I felt too dirty and ashamed to care. Some might say I was ashamed of the Gospel, but I don’t think that was it at all. I don’t think that what we had done had much to do with the gospel at all.

Does Street Evangelism Work?

So I am not a fan of any of the three forms of street evangelism we have looked at so far. They show nothing of the neighborly love or sacrificial service that are central to the biblical gospel. Granted, there’s no telling what the Holy Spirit might do, or who He might use to bring people to Jesus, but I always have to wonder when I encounter such street preachers if there might be a better, more gentle, personal, forgiving way of drawing people to Jesus Christ.

As Nathan L. K. Bierma points out, such street-evangelism techniques seem “to have found the most alienating way to talk to people (or at people), the way that involves the least listening, the least smiling, the least humility, the least possibility of getting anything but a cold shoulder in return” (Bringing Heaven Down to Earth, 136).

Have you ever done any street evangelism? What was your experience with it? What did you do? How did you feel? What happened as a result?

Yesterday, we looked at one form of street evangelism: bullhorn evangelism. Another form is Sandwich Board Evangelism.

In college, I encountered another form of street preaching: the sandwich board preacher. I was attending the state university, and one day, on my way to class, I noticed a large crowd gathering around a man with a sandwich sign strapped to his shoulders. Next to him stood a young girl, probably around ten years old, dressed all in white. I found out later this was his daughter.

The sign, however, caught my eyes. In big, bold, burning, red letters across the top it read: “GOD HATES…” and then scattered around the rest of the board were groups of people that God hates: liars, cheaters, atheists, drunks, adulterers, and gays (he used a different word, which I won’t include here).

He also had a bullhorn, and was busy announcing to the growing crowd of college students that all sinners were going to hell. He claimed that he had not sinned in 21 years, and his ten year-old daughter had never sinned in her entire life.

Some Christians who were there tried to argue with him from 1 John 1:8, that the one who says they have not sinned is a liar.

His response was that he wasn’t claiming he had not sinned. He had. Twenty-one years ago. And his daughter wasn’t claiming she had not sinned. He, the father, was making that claim. So 1 John 1:8 didn’t apply to either one of them. Nice, huh?

I can’t be certain, but I don’t think he got any “converts” that day, or even moved anybody in the right direction. So far, the bullhorn evangelist Red was up on this guy by one.

Probably the worst form of evangelism is street evangelism. It comes in several forms.

The first type is Bullhorn Evangelism. I know that some people do get saved through these sorts of street preachers, but for every one person who receives eternal life, hundreds more are turned off by such a presentation of Christ and Christianity.

The Evangelism of Red

When I was growing up, there was a street in town with lots of bars on it, and it had a regular patron named Red. And though he was often surrounded by empty beer cans and other assorted trash, he never entered a bar and never had a drink. The bottles and cans were thrown at him by drunk revelers. Why? Because every night he walked up and down the street, waving his Bible in the air and shouting his version of the Gospel through a bullhorn. When people threw bottles and cans at him, Red loved it all the more, because he thought he was enduring persecution for the cause of Christ.

Looking back now, I wonder who was persecuting whom?

[Read more…]

In previous series of posts, we have looked at two areas where churches often spend too much time talking and not enough doing: Doctrinal Statements and Prayer Meetings. The third area is evangelism.

Talking About the Gospel

For far too many people, evangelism is equivalent to talking. Preachers give evangelistic sermons where they tell people about the Gospel; evangelists go out to street corners and pass out gospel tracts while shouting Scriptures through a bull horn. When churches engage in door-to-door evangelism, they walk around a neighborhood, knocking on doors to tell others about Jesus.

Which is why I say, “Enough with Evangelism!” Or at least, enough with this kind of evangelism. I am all for evangelism, but not for the kind which does little more than inundate people with words upon words. In the following chapter, I will issue a call to cancel several word-heavy evangelistic programs, and exchange them for a way of life that lives and shares the gospel in a tangible way with others.

Background to Evangelism

But first, a little background. While it is true that many of the evangelistic events we read about in the Gospels and Acts by Jesus and the Apostles were heavy on words, there is a big difference between then and now which we must not overlook.

[Read more…]

Chapter 11 in my book, Close Your Church for Good, is called “Enough with Evangelism.”

In this chapter, we look at some of the forms of evangelism today, and how they amount to little more than talking at people, which is not Scriptural and does more damage to the Gospel than good. To live and practice the way of love as modeled by Jesus, one step we can take is to stop our evangelism strategies and techniques, and start living the principles of the Kingdom within our communities.

Please note that due to some of the feedback I receive on these posts, this chapter might be radically revised for the final edition of the book. These changes will only be available in the print or eBook version when it comes out.
[Read more…]